Home » Blog » Nutrition for Healthy Bones » Collagen vs Whey Protein: What’s Best For You?

Collagen vs Whey Protein: What’s Best For You?

The protein supplement landscape can be confusing. Whey-based, plant-based, egg-based and meat-based proteins exist out there. And then there is collagen. How do you choose?

This article will focus on the differences and similarities between collagen and whey protein.It will help you to make a decision about which is best for you.

Let’s get started.

What is collagen?

Collagen is the most plentiful protein in your body. Skin, bones, ligaments, tendons, cartilage, blood vessels, your intestinal lining, and many of your organs all contain collagen.

Collagen is:

Found in animal products
A super strong molecule
Not a complete protein

Collagen is made in the bodies of humans and animals. This is why formed collagen only comes from animal products. So what is the form of collagen?

Amino acids are the building blocks that make up proteins. Collagen is made of three chains of amino acids that are linked together in interlocking strands. It is an incredibly strong structure that literally holds your body together.

Created by User:Vossman This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license. Subject to disclaimers. 

The three main amino acids that make up collagen are glycine, proline and hydroxyproline. There are other amino acids in the mix, but in smaller quantities. Collagen is not a complete or high quality protein. It doesn’t have enough of the essential amino acids.

Essential amino acids are the ones that we need to get from food.

What is whey protein?

Whey protein comes from milk. Liquid whey actually comes from the cheese-making process. Milk is separated into curds and whey. Curd is the part that gets turned into cheese. Whey can go on to become whey protein.

Whey protein is:

Made from milk
A complete, high quality protein

There is a whole process whereby the protein is isolated from the whey. Lactose (sugar) and minerals are washed out, leaving a mixture that is 90-95% pure protein (1).  

Whey protein has a much wider range of amino acids than collagen. Whey contains enough of the essential amino acids, which we need to get from food, to be considered a complete protein. 

Which is better, collagen or whey protein?

Is collagen or whey protein better for your gut?

Both whey protein and collagen peptides can be beneficial for your gut. Let’s see if one has an advantage.

Whey is a particularly good source of glutamine. Glutamine is the fuel that feeds the cells that line your digestive tract (2).  

These cells lining your gut get sloughed off every 5 days or so. Then they need to be regrown. Glutamine provides the fuel to keep healthy new cells coming online.

Collagen also contains substantial amounts of glycine and glutamine, which are important amino acids to heal and maintain your gut lining (3).  

One difference between whey protein and collagen when it comes to your gut is that collagen is very low or lacking in tryptophan. Tryptophan is an amino acid that regulates gut immunity and metabolism, gut microbiota, intestinal barrier, and transit time (4).

Whey protein is a good source of tryptophan.

There is also some evidence that whey protein can promote growth of beneficial bacteria, like Bifidobacterium and Lactobacillus, in the gut (5).

My pick for the gut is whey protein.

Is collagen or whey protein better for your bones?

Collagen peptides have large amounts of the specific amino acids that build up your bone matrix.

There is a considerable amount of research in animals and in vitro studies showing that collagen peptides can increase bone formation and bone density. A randomized controlled study in 2018 showed significant improvements in bone mineral density in the spine and femoral neck of postmenopausal women (6).  

There is also research showing that milk and milk products are beneficial for bone health (7). However studies using whole milk and milk products might not apply to isolated whey protein.

A study published in 2022 did not report significant changes in markers of bone turnover after 12 weeks of whey supplementation in adults with higher weights (8). It’s possible if this study had gone on longer they might have noticed a change, or results might be different in adults of normal weight or underweight.

We do know that protein is essential to increase bone density and formation, and whey protein is an excellent protein source. But as a supplement it might not be any better than other forms of protein. 

Because there is better research to support it, my pick for the bones is collagen peptides.

Is collagen or whey protein better for muscle growth?

Whey protein contains all the essential amino acids, including branched chain amino acids. Branched chain amino acids like leucine are especially important for muscle growth (9). Leucine is believed to be the trigger that starts the anabolic process of building up muscle. 

Pure collagen does not contain branched chain amino acids like leucine.

A meta-analysis published in 2024 found that whey protein supplements increased muscle mass and physical performance in older patients with sarcopenia. When it was combined with resistance exercise, whey protein also increased muscle strength (10).   

Similar results were found in a meta-analysis of the research on whey protein supplementation and postmenopausal women (11).   

Another study found that collagen peptides increased muscle mass and strength in older men with sarcopenia. However they were compared with a control group that was taking silica, which contains no protein. It makes sense that any protein product might have improved their muscle mass (12).  

When you compare collagen with whey protein, whey is superior for increasing muscle mass (13).   

My pick for building muscle is whey protein.

Is collagen or whey protein better for weight loss and metabolic health?

A recent study tested whether collagen peptide supplements can help adults over the age of 50 to reduce body fat (14). Participants in this randomized controlled trial took 15 grams of collagen peptides a day for 12 weeks, or a similar tasting placebo. There was no change in physical activity or dietary intake. There was a significant reduction in body weight, waist to hip ratio and visceral fat.

It isn’t clear in this study whether any other type of protein supplementation would have had the same effect.

You could argue that if someone eats a low protein diet to begin with, any type of protein supplement is going to improve their metabolic health. But another study actually compared whey protein with collagen.

A randomized controlled double blind study in 2019 compared the impact of whey protein and collagen supplementation for women’s metabolic health. They found that supplementing for eight weeks with 40 g/day of whey protein (vs 38 g/day of collagen protein in the control group) reduced the android fat and increased secretion of Nesfatin in women with higher weights (15).   

Android fat is distributed around the trunk and upper body. Nesfatin is a peptide that regulates energy balance.

The branched chain amino acids in whey protein are associated with feeling satisfied after you eat, regulating your food intake, and losing lean body mass. In this study, the collagen group actually had an increase in body weight (15).  

My pick for weight loss and metabolic health is whey protein.

Can collagen replace protein powder?

Collagen is not an adequate replacement for protein powder. It lacks several important amino acids, like tryptophan and leucine. If you use collagen as your sole protein supplement, you must make sure you are getting these nutrients somewhere else.

Collagen vs whey protein: which is right for you?

Here are some questions to help you decide between collagen or whey protein.

Can you tolerate milk products? Whey protein is a milk product. If your problem is lactose, which is the sugar in milk, you may still be able to tolerate whey protein. Most of the lactose is removed in the making of whey protein.

If you don’t tolerate milk protein, then whey protein may not be right for you.

Are you okay with eating a product made from an animal? All formed collagen comes from animals. This is usually cows, or some types of fish and other marine life. Whey comes from milk, so a cow did not actually give their life for it. 

Read more about how collagen is produced.   

What do you want the protein to do for you? Do you want stronger bones, better skin, bigger muscles or a healthier gut? Different sources of protein are going to work differently in your body. 

What does the rest of your diet look like? Since collagen is a low quality protein (great for some amino acids, but lacking others), you do not want to rely on it to provide all of your protein needs. Make sure you are getting enough in foods, or combine it with a higher quality protein.

Are you prone to developing calcium oxalate kidney stones? Collagen contains hydroxyproline. Your body metabolizes hydroxyproline to glyoxylate. Glyoxylate can significantly increase the amount of urinary oxalates that the kidneys excrete (16).

Final Thoughts

Collagen is a supplemental form of protein that comes from animal sources, usually beef or marine animals. Whey protein comes from the liquid part of the milk that is left in the cheese-making process.

There are pros and cons to each of these types of protein. While they are both good for your gut, whey protein has a slight edge. There is a lot of evidence showing that collagen peptides are beneficial for bone health. Whey protein appears to be more helpful for weight loss and metabolic health.

Your decision whether to use whey protein or collagen depends on your food preferences, your lifestyle, and the results you are looking for.

Could you use some help figuring out what you should eat, and which supplements are best for you? I’d love to talk to you. Just click the button below to learn how.

 

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top