You want to take collagen for stronger bones. You also want the complete amino acid profile of whey protein. Are you wondering if you can take collagen and whey protein together?
In this article I will explain some similarities and differences between these two types of protein, and how to combine them to meet all of your needs.
Let’s start answering your questions.
Table of Contents
Can you take collagen and whey protein together?
Yes, you can absolutely take these two protein supplements together. You can combine them and take both at once, or you can take them each at different times during the day. Both collagen and whey protein can play a part in filling your needs for muscle and bone strength.
Let’s look in more detail at the difference between these two proteins, and the benefits of each.
What are the differences between collagen and whey protein?
First let’s mention one way these two proteins are the same. Both collagen and whey protein come from animal sources. If you do not eat animal products neither will be right for you.
Here are some differences between collagen and whey protein:
- Whey is a complete, high quality protein. Collagen is not a complete protein. It is missing tryptophan, an essential amino acid that you need to build both muscle and neurotransmitters.
- Whey is a dairy (milk) product, while collagen is dairy-free.
What if you are dairy free?
If you are dairy free, I don’t recommend taking whey protein. If you still eat other animal products, you can take collagen. However you will want to make sure you get the missing amino acid, tryptophan. You can use a plant based protein to supplement your collagen.
Pumpkin seed is an excellent plant based source of tryptophan (1). You can buy pumpkin seed protein from Sprout Living.
Which is better, collagen or whey protein?
The answer to which protein is better depends on what results you are looking for.
Research supports the benefits of collagen to increase bone formation and density (2).
Both collagen and whey protein have gut-healing properties. However the extra amino acids in whey protein are especially beneficial for your gut, and whey encourages growth of good gut bacteria (3) (4).
Whey protein is more beneficial for building muscle due to its superior amino acid profile (5).
If you are trying to lose weight, you may be more successful when supplementing with whey protein rather than collagen (6).
Read more about collagen vs whey protein.
So, what if you want the muscle-building benefits of whey, but also want to increase your bone density? The good news is that you can take both collagen and whey protein together.
When and how should you take collagen and whey protein?
Both collagen peptides and whey protein are easy to digest. You can take them with meals if that is convenient, or on an empty stomach. In all cases you should follow the directions on the product that you choose.
Some people like to mix collagen in with their morning coffee. You could add collagen or whey to a smoothie. You can also add whey protein to a food like oatmeal.
Personally I like to mix whey protein in a small glass of water and take it at night before I go to bed.
It’s a good idea to spread your protein out evenly throughout the day, rather than taking it all at once. However, your best plan depends on things like how much protein you are able to eat at meals, and whether your activity level demands extra protein for muscle repair.
The bottom line is that these proteins are flexible, and can be mixed or taken separately any time of the day. The important thing is finding a time and method that will work best for you.
Who should not take collagen and/or whey protein?
If you are under a doctor’s care for any medical condition, consult with them before starting any new supplement.
If you are prone to calcium oxalate kidney stones, you might want to rethink collagen. Collagen contains an amino acid called hydroxyproline. Your body metabolizes hydroxyproline to glyoxylate. The oxalate in glyoxylate is excreted by the kidneys. This can increase the risk of kidney stone formation (7).
If you are pregnant or breastfeeding, check with your doctor before taking any supplement. The protein itself or any of the other ingredients might be contraindicated for you.
If you are allergic to milk protein, it goes without saying that you should not take a supplement that contains milk proteins. Also, those with fish allergies should stay away from collagen supplements made from marine animals.
Some people with Mast Cell Activation Syndrome or histamine intolerance may not be able to tolerate collagen. This could be because of histamines in the collagen itself, other ingredients in the product, or the fact that collagen might be a histamine liberator (8).
According to the SIGHI list, whey is generally well tolerated when it comes to histamine.
This is not a complete list of conditions that should not take whey or collagen supplements. Since I don’t know the health history of everyone who reads this blog, it is impossible for me to advise whether you should take these protein supplements.
How much collagen and whey protein should you take?
In a study showing benefits of collagen peptides for bone density, participants took 5 grams of collagen peptides per day for 12 months (2). This is considerably less than the serving size of most collagen supplements out there on the market.
In the weight loss study, the whey group took 25 grams of whey protein, and the collagen group took 26 grams of collagen (6).
In the resistance training study that looked at muscle growth, the two groups took either 35 grams of whey protein or 35 grams of collagen protein (5).
So you can see that the amount used in these studies is similar to or less than what people take in real life. The amount you should take depends on your own situation. How much protein do you need overall, based on your age, health and lifestyle? How much protein are you already getting in your diet? Are you getting all the other nutrients you need to build bone and muscle effectively?
I am happy to help you to sort out the answers to these questions. At the end of this article you’ll find a link where you can schedule a call to find out more about working with me.
The Last Word
Whey protein and collagen both come from animal sources. Collagen is dairy free, but whey is made from milk.
Whey is a complete protein, and is a better choice for building muscle, promoting better metabolic health and nourishing your gut. Collagen is missing an essential amino acid, and considered a low quality protein.
However, research shows collagen is very effective for increasing bone formation and density. It does contain a lot of the specific amino acids used in bones and cartilage.
You can combine collagen and whey protein to get the benefits of both. Unless you have an allergy or specific food intolerance, collagen peptides and whey are both easily digested and absorbed.